Sunday, 10 June 2012
Behavioural Disorders---What are they???
Children and youth with behavioural disorders exhibit a spectrum of behaviours ranging from disruptive and contancerous outbursts to severe withdrawal from social interaction. Dozens of different characteristics have been attributed to these children and youth. There is no such thing as a typical child with a behaviour disorder; the only commonality is that the excesses are chronic and extend far beyond the norm. Given the varied behaviours and uniqueness of every affected individual, definitions, terminology and classifications are very confused.
All behavioural disorders are abnormal in the sense that the word means "away from the norm", and behavioural disorders are deviations from average or standard behaviour. It is hard to draw the line between serious behavioural disorders and problematic behaviour that is fairly common in childhood. All children exhibit varying behaviours, and deviant and unusual behaviours may exist in the repertoires of those
who are developing normally. Children who have behavioural challenges sometimes behave quite normally. Distinctions between normal and disturbed behaviour are generally in the amount and/or degree rather than kind. Children with behavioural disorders perform certain behaviours too often or intensely, or not often or intensely enough, but specifing this amount and degree is difficult.
The field of behavioural disabilities has seen evolving terminology over the years. At the onset, a variety of descriptors, largely arising from a psychiatric base, were used: neurotic, psychotic, obsessive, and emotionally distrubed. Current educators prefer to dispense with psychiatric terms, but still disagree over what constitutes a severe behaviour disorder, whether the use of term is even justifiable, and whether to call these children emotionally disturbed, behaviourally disordered, socially maladjusted, deviant, psychologically impaired, educationally handicapped, character disordered, children in conflict, delinquent, or some other descriptor. Given the varied terminology, it is not surprising that numerous ways to define behavioural disorders have emerged over the years, but a universally accepted definition remains extremely problematic.
To make diagnosis even more challenging, there is no single symptom that is common to all pupils who are behaviourally disordered or even to a subgroup of these children, because there is no such thing as a typical student who is behaviourally disordered. Some (but not all) children are versitile in their antisocial behaviour, and likely to display a wide variety of inappropriate behaviours or more than one type of problem or disorder. A child with a conduct disorder may also be depressed, and that child's behaviour may vacillate to such a degree as to show both internalizing and externalizing problems. Some children who show versatile antisocial behaviour are, generally likely to have the more severe problems, and their prognosis is usually poorer compared to those who exhibit only one type of antisocial behaviour.
Behavioural disorders cannot be measured quatitively. We have no instruments analogous to the I.Q. test to determine a mental health quotient. Behavioural problems also change as children get older. A child who frequently disobeyed their parents, might, as a teenager, engage in vandalism and delinquency. Identification can also occur at any age and is usually made by parents or teachers whose expectations and tolerance levels differ by the individual doing the identifying. Teachers place different demands on students depending upon their own behavioural standards and the degree to which they are accepting of specific maladaptive behaviours.
The field of behavioural disabilities has seen evolving terminology over the years. At the onset, a variety of descriptors, largely arising from a psychiatric base, were used: neurotic, psychotic, obsessive, and emotionally distrubed. Current educators prefer to dispense with psychiatric terms, but still disagree over what constitutes a severe behaviour disorder, whether the use of term is even justifiable, and whether to call these children emotionally disturbed, behaviourally disordered, socially maladjusted, deviant, psychologically impaired, educationally handicapped, character disordered, children in conflict, delinquent, or some other descriptor. Given the varied terminology, it is not surprising that numerous ways to define behavioural disorders have emerged over the years, but a universally accepted definition remains extremely problematic.
To make diagnosis even more challenging, there is no single symptom that is common to all pupils who are behaviourally disordered or even to a subgroup of these children, because there is no such thing as a typical student who is behaviourally disordered. Some (but not all) children are versitile in their antisocial behaviour, and likely to display a wide variety of inappropriate behaviours or more than one type of problem or disorder. A child with a conduct disorder may also be depressed, and that child's behaviour may vacillate to such a degree as to show both internalizing and externalizing problems. Some children who show versatile antisocial behaviour are, generally likely to have the more severe problems, and their prognosis is usually poorer compared to those who exhibit only one type of antisocial behaviour.
Behavioural disorders cannot be measured quatitively. We have no instruments analogous to the I.Q. test to determine a mental health quotient. Behavioural problems also change as children get older. A child who frequently disobeyed their parents, might, as a teenager, engage in vandalism and delinquency. Identification can also occur at any age and is usually made by parents or teachers whose expectations and tolerance levels differ by the individual doing the identifying. Teachers place different demands on students depending upon their own behavioural standards and the degree to which they are accepting of specific maladaptive behaviours.
Once diagnosed, most children with behavioural disabilities are considered to struggle with one or more of the following:
- conduct disorders
-anxiety and withdrawal
-socialized aggression
-ADHD
-childhood psychosis
-anxiety and withdrawal
-socialized aggression
-ADHD
-childhood psychosis
The two most common are aggressive behaviour (acting out) and social withdrawal. It is important to remember that no child is the same.
Prevelance
Based on media reports, it would seem that the incidence of behavioural disorders has increased dramatically during the last few decades. Teachers, on the other hand, found behaviour was neither increasing or decreasing. Although mounting numbers are being identified as behaviourally disordered, accurate figures are not available chiefly because of the lack of a clear and precise definitional construct.
In Canada, a national study by the Canadian Institute of Child Health (2000) reported that the rates of behaviioural and emotional problems for children aged 4 to 11 is "disturbingly high", with 1 in 10 children exhibiting behaviour consistent with hyperactivity problems, conduct disorder, or an emotional disorder. Boys (6-16%) do get diagnosed for behavioural disorders more often than girls (2-9%). One has to wonder if
In Canada, a national study by the Canadian Institute of Child Health (2000) reported that the rates of behaviioural and emotional problems for children aged 4 to 11 is "disturbingly high", with 1 in 10 children exhibiting behaviour consistent with hyperactivity problems, conduct disorder, or an emotional disorder. Boys (6-16%) do get diagnosed for behavioural disorders more often than girls (2-9%). One has to wonder if
this has anything to do with the expectations of students behaviour in school settings. Considering that boys often function differently than girls and at different rates, could some of their diagnosis' be due to their different learning styles? Certainly, too, different behavioural problems are more prevelant in boys (such as aggression), while others are more prevalent in girls (anxiety). All the same, all behavioural disabilities can effect
both genders. As well, the prevalence of behavioural disorders are consistantly low in the beginning grades, peak in middle school and tend to fall off in highschool. This does not mean that the issues will go away with time. Intervention, as early as possible, is essential in helping these children manage their behaviour and not lose their social, emotional and psychological skills. In order to grow into strong, confident adults, they will need these skills for a strong self-esteem and self-image.
Behavioural disorders often are bi-products of other learning disorders too. A child suffering from physical, social, emotional or learning challenges is often frustrated or anxious, thus, reflecting poor behavioural symptoms. Behavioural problems can be the result of trama or stresses at home or with peers, coming out only in highly stressful situations like the classroom or anywhere the child lacks confidence. Because there are so many different origins and causes and so many types of diagnosis, behavioural disabilities are challenging to identify and treat. Yet it is still very important to address these issues because of how many children are affected and the impact it can have on their success.
Behavioural disorders often are bi-products of other learning disorders too. A child suffering from physical, social, emotional or learning challenges is often frustrated or anxious, thus, reflecting poor behavioural symptoms. Behavioural problems can be the result of trama or stresses at home or with peers, coming out only in highly stressful situations like the classroom or anywhere the child lacks confidence. Because there are so many different origins and causes and so many types of diagnosis, behavioural disabilities are challenging to identify and treat. Yet it is still very important to address these issues because of how many children are affected and the impact it can have on their success.
Etiology
Despite the vast amount of research, nobody fully understands the causes of any type of psychopathy and there is no evidence linking any behavioural disorders to any specific cause. Behavioural disorders occur among the rich, poor, gifted, intellectually disabled, and members of all racial and ethnic groups. Because social and cultural expectations differ, there are varying reactions to certain behaviours. Deviance is
defined by social groups that recognize some behaviours as infractions of the rules and label as deviant persons who do not conform to these socially defined rules. This explains, at least in part why a disapropriate number of students from culturally and linguistically different groups are labelled as behaviourally disordered.
Here are some possible causes for behavioural disorders:
Here are some possible causes for behavioural disorders:
Definitions
The most widely used classification system was formed by Quay and his collegues; they came up with 5 major types of behavioural disorders:
1) Conduct Disorder
2) Anxiety & Withdrawal
3) Socialized Aggression
4) Attention Disorders & Motor Excess (ADHD)
5) Psychotic Behaviour
2) Anxiety & Withdrawal
3) Socialized Aggression
4) Attention Disorders & Motor Excess (ADHD)
5) Psychotic Behaviour
Conduct Disorder
-most common
-overt, aggressive, disruptive behaviour or covert antisocial acts that are breaking the social rules and as a result violate social norms and the rights of others
-volatile, unpredictable, hyperactive and disputive behaviour
-engage in attention-getting, limit-testing defiance, challenges, disrespectful, verbally abusive, blatant rule violations, threats and intimidation
-non-compliance, failing to follow ADULT rules and because they have failed to develop reliable internal controls, they often seem to not know right from wrong
-characterized behaviours are not age-appropriate
-overt, aggressive, disruptive behaviour or covert antisocial acts that are breaking the social rules and as a result violate social norms and the rights of others
-volatile, unpredictable, hyperactive and disputive behaviour
-engage in attention-getting, limit-testing defiance, challenges, disrespectful, verbally abusive, blatant rule violations, threats and intimidation
-non-compliance, failing to follow ADULT rules and because they have failed to develop reliable internal controls, they often seem to not know right from wrong
-characterized behaviours are not age-appropriate
Subcatagories are Aggressive Behaviour and ODD (Oppositional Defiant Disorders).
Aggressive Behaviour involves verbal, non-verbal and physical behaviour that injure others directly or indirectly and/or results in extraneous gains
for the aggressor (Zirpoli and Mellory, 1997, pg 339)
ODD is characterized by consistantly negavitistic, hostile and defiant behaviour, particularly towards adults. These children frequently argue, show resentment, are touchy, spiteful, angry and vindictive and throw many temper-tantrums. This form of conduct disorder often develops into a worse condition later.
Anxiety and Withdrawal
Currently there are 14 catagories of anxiety disorders, the most common being obsessive compulsive disorder, separation anxiety disorder, post-tramatic stress disorder, generalized anxiety disorder and social phobia.
Anxiety is a fear of future reference, characterized by worry, tension, uneasiness, and fears of what could happen, esspecially around new situations and people. It is abnormal when it occurs in situations that most people can handle with little difficulty.
"Generalized Anxiety" is present all the time and may include phobias (fears of specific things). These children suffer from nausea, abdominal pain and often express their fears by crying, sadness and depression. This disorder is more common in girls than boys, but school phobia.
-affects 2% from age 5-15years equally.
Obsessive-compulsive disorders are recurrent obsessions and /or compulsions that interfere with daily life and cause distress. Obsessions are persistant ideas that are experienced as intrusive or inappropriate. Compulsions are repeated behaviours or acts to reduce stress and anxiety, but not for pleasure or gratification. Disorders can result in disgust, discomfort and guilt. These children are often withdrawn, secretive,
apathetic, day-dream and fanatsize instead of socializing. They may experience depression, lose interest in activities, feel worthless and guilty, and have difficulty thinking, concentrating and making decisions.
Socialized Aggression
Children and youth with discipline problems at school, seem to have the same issues outside of school.
These issues are more social, than emotional or behavioural. Children socializing in delinquent peer groups who reinforce poor behaviour in a positive way, are encouraged to fall into the pattern of repeated offences. Violence, non-compliance, bullying, intimidation, gang vandalism, stealing, fighting, truancy and sexual assault are encouraged in these social groups. Often this behaviour gets worse and more serious over time.
These issues are more social, than emotional or behavioural. Children socializing in delinquent peer groups who reinforce poor behaviour in a positive way, are encouraged to fall into the pattern of repeated offences. Violence, non-compliance, bullying, intimidation, gang vandalism, stealing, fighting, truancy and sexual assault are encouraged in these social groups. Often this behaviour gets worse and more serious over time.
Attention Disorders
-a persistent pattern of inattention and/or hyperactivity/impulsivity that is more frequent and severe than is typically the norm
-inattention, impulsivity, hyperactivity
-difficulty concentrating, tuning in and actively participating
-bounce from one activity to the next, active, easily distracted by visual and auditory stimuli
-difficulty taking turns, interupts and cannot sit still
-high intelligence or at least average
-inattention, impulsivity, hyperactivity
-difficulty concentrating, tuning in and actively participating
-bounce from one activity to the next, active, easily distracted by visual and auditory stimuli
-difficulty taking turns, interupts and cannot sit still
-high intelligence or at least average
-ADHD is the most common form of attention disorder.
Psychological Disorders
Austism, Aspergers, childhood disintegrative disorders, Retts, childhood psychosis, schizophenia, developmental disorders and combinations of these are psychologic disorders. They are physiological conditions that can cause unusual behaviour as a result.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Test Yourself...
http://psychcentral.com/addquiz.htm
http://psychcentral.com/cgi-bin/addquiz.cgiText Yourself for ADHD
http://psychcentral.com/cgi-bin/addquiz.cgiText Yourself for ADHD
Looking back, although never formally diagnosed, I'm pretty sure I know someone who displayed the characteristics of O.D.D. Back 15-20 years ago, I'm not so sure that I remember ever hearing the term Oppositional Defiant Disorder. In our text book it says that the behaviours must be present for at least six months, this boy/man is still displaying a lot of the characteristics. I am wondering how do you really distinguish wheather the person really is suffering from a disorder or if it is just their personality? I know at the time, the comments made about this child were things like, "yes he "strong willed" now but this is going to be great when he is older - no one will ever walk all over him". Today this young man is still "strong willed", does know what he wants and when he wants it, speaks up for himself, is a very hard worker, has great social skills and is very successful in all that he does. I am wondering if back those many years ago, if that child had of been labelled and treated for O.D.D. would he have turned out as successful as he is today?
ReplyDeleteFor five years I have had a client who is a young lady now, but has had a lot of issues with Anxiety and Withdrawal(post traumatic stress disorder, generalized anxiety disorder and social phobia). When i first started working with her, she was a young girl of 12 years old. Having been molested by her biolgoical father at a young age she didn't trust people...anyone. I had the task of trying to encourage her to go to school, the store, the mall, for a walk in a public place, and to Dr's appointments/counselling. It took along time to earn her trust, but thankfully it happened. With a lot of patience and perseverance I am pleased to say that she has now formed a few friendships with peers, will go to the store/mall with someone else, has been attending Dr's/counselling services, and is attending school(but not consistently). Although she is slowly learning coping techniques, this is something she will have to live with for the rest of her life.
ReplyDeleteUnless you know of someone who is or has gone through these anxieties it is difficult to totally comprehend and understand their daily struggles.
My son suffers from severe anxiety. It can and does affect almost every aspect of his day to day living. I worry that schools do not do enough to help these kids as they tend to withdraw into their own world. I am fortunate enough to have my children attend an amazing school where the teachers and staff have worked with both myself and my son to ensure he has coping strategies, a safe place and plan for when the anxiety gets to be too much, and just an acceptance that this is who he is. However, once myself and the school realized something was not quite right with my son, I immediately began seeking out professional help. I had to way over a year for a therapists counseling consultation. She agreed that my son would benefite. he went thru a 12 week program and it was very helpful. At the end of the 12 week program she informed me that while it would continue to be beneficial for my son to attend more sessions, that because of new policy at the hospital, they would only continue to see my son if he became a danger to himself or others. I found this very sad and disgusting that I could only get help when my son reached a severe point with his anxiety, but not for the preventive measures. Very frustrating and concerning.
ReplyDeleteI am very sorry to hear about the frustrations you have encountered with your son. Don’t give up hope, and keep being the supportive Mom you are! My daughter also suffers with behaviour disorders. She has been seeing a child psychiatrist at McMaster Hospital, in Hamilton, for over a year now. She takes several strong medications for her anxiety disorder and obsessive/compulsive issues. Yes she is causing harm to herself physically. It is part of an emotional/stress cycle we don’t understand. Her psychiatrist is trying hard to get her help here locally, in the K-W area, but is finding it very difficult to find anyone to take her on. It seems to be a matter of $ and too many other patients. Mental health issues in children and teenagers are definitely becoming more common – or at least being recognized more. Our daughter is lucky in that she is at least seeing someone. Although, no one has found the magic answers to help her, to help herself. I appreciate what the group above put in the blog: The more positive environment we can create for them, the greater the chance for giving that child the opportunity they deserve to succeed in life. It is very true.
DeleteIt's too bad when it come to the welfare of our children we have to be at the mercy of hospital policies and politics. If you are the average person without an over abundance of cash, you and your family has to suffer and wait for necessary treatment.
DeleteIt seems as though children today have so many more mental health issues. Are we putting too much pressure on kids today to succeed? More research is being done on mental health issues and inturn we are becoming more aware of them as parents. Mental health issues should be taking very seriously. As parents we need to educate ourselves and learn what our children are struggling with.
ReplyDeleteI think that more pressure is put on our children in school today so that they can score well on provincial testing. When I was young we weren't expected to start reading until we were in grade one and now if your child can't read by grade one they are already behind. They are learning things much earlier now and are given amazing amounts of homework at a young age, it's no wonder the incidence of mental health issues is rising.
DeleteAs future EAs, we will all no doubt get to work with children showing a broad range of behavioural difficulties. Some of us may routinely be required to fill out Behaviour Logs and Incidence Reports. As per the Weber text (p.110) we must remember "...it is often important to look beyond what is occurring to why it is occurring." We will have the opportunity to track behaviours and hopefully figure out some reasons behind outbursts. By starting to unravel the mystery of an individual's behaviour, we will be helping the student who may not be able to help themselves.
ReplyDeleteAs a person who was considered 'behavioural' as a child, I am sure that it is very difficult to work with them and since I had experience with other children like myself I know that it can be very challenging handling them.
ReplyDeleteBehavioural disorders are scary for every one involved but gives students a great opportunity to learn how to deal with more difficult people thta they will most likely encounter in their every day lives as adults. I feel with the right support from staff and parents all studentys can benefit from the inclusion of chidlren with behavioural dissabilties.
ReplyDeleteMy daughter suffers from anxiety, OCD and PTSD, all of which I have worked hard to get under control. This year I had my daughter attend Art Therapy in a group setting and well and one on one Play Therapy. The Art Therapy was a 10 week program which was held out of the Cambridge Self Help Food Bank. When she completed the course, the therapist pulled me aside and told me she couldn't believe the changes which had occured in her in such a short time. I believe that the art therapy, along with the play therapy worked wonders. She did 5 months of biweekly play therapy and during her last session, the counsellor told us she no longer thinks we need to continue. As for at school, she had such an incredible teacher who was sensitive to her needs. My daughter, who cried and had to be physically given to her teacher until January, went up and did a play in front of 450 people in June and all without a single tear. I have never felt such pride in my life. I believe with a lot of love, commitment and hard work, children who suffer with anxiety issues can be helped and cured. It's so easy to feel overwhelmed and want to give up but as parents, care givers and people who have such influence over children we cannot give up, no matter how long it takes. Lisa, I highly recommed finding a play and/or art therapist to help your son and family work through his anxiety issues, not only do they enjoy what they are doing, I find it was easier for my daughter to talk about her issues than with a child psycologist for mostof the time, she didn't even realize she was discussing her problems and fears which allievated the extra stress.
ReplyDeleteI really strongly agree with the Socialized Aggression with children and youth.I think that with some students it is more social and them being in the "in" crowed while impressing their peers.When they are getting credited by other peers for bad behaviour and getting excepted by them, they feel like they are doing something right for once and fitting in. Growing up with some people that when i was younger and they were class a students and once hitting highschool watching them totally doing a 180 while doing things you would not expect them to do.Its very sad to see that.
ReplyDeleteA tough subject to cover in a short blog. but you did a good job of explaining it well. I also liked your use of graphs and charts.
ReplyDeleteIt is important to recognize the varying degrees of behavioural issues. I feel we sometimes in Education tend to lump many of these students together that may have extremely different problems relating to behaviour. Dissevering the various types of behavioural problems is crucial for how to best teach that particular student. This was a very well organized and insightful blog.
Behavioural exceptionalities seem to become more and more prevlant. I feel it is a reflection of the environmental demands of the school. The expectations for these students are too high, and when children cannot achieve them it can be damaging to the students self confidence and academic achievement. Some children tend to act out as they are not getting the assistance that they require. Teachers do not always have the skills to handle children with these special needs. This is what makes EA's and the support team so invaluable to the school community.
ReplyDelete